Home > Missions > Regulatory > Regulatory Appeals > Administrative Appeals Decisions

Appeal Decisions

 

Current Appeals

District

Appellant

Processing # Type of Appeal Date Received Date Completed
   

Completed Appeals

District

Appellant

Processing # Type of Appeal Date Received Date Completed Appeal Decision Final District Action
 Sacramento  Stegall and Herdbuilders, Colusa County, CA  SPK-2012-00991  Proffered Permit  12/02/2015   10/19/2016  Had Merit  Pending
 Sacramento  Lund, Sacramento County, CA   SPK-2013-00533  Proffered Permit   2/09/2015   6/25/2015  No Merit  Not Applicable
 Sacramento  North San Joaquin Water Conservation District North  SPK-2011-01069  Jurisdictional Determination  12/23/2014  9/09/2015  Had Merit  Partially Disclaimed Jurisdiction Following Reevaluation
San Francisco  Frazier Lake Farms, San Benito County, California  SPN-2011-00146S Jurisdictional Determination  11/29/2013 10/22/2014  No Merit Not Applicable 
San Francisco  Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District Property, California  SPN-2012-00301N Jurisdictional Determination 7/9/2013 9/8/2014  Had Merit  District Disclaimed Jurisdiction Following Reevaluation
Albuquerque South Pino Arroyo, Bernalillo County, New Mexico  SPA-2012-00190  Jurisdictional Determination  1/14/2013  6/26/2014  No Merit Not Applicable
San Francisco Zeneca Property, California  SPN-2003-28252   Jurisdictional Determination 1/25/2013  12/19/2013  Had Merit  Maintained Jurisdiction Following Reconsideration
Sacramento  Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance  SPK-2013-00295-UO  Jurisdictional Determination 8/28/2013  10/17/2013  Not Accepted  Not Applicable 
Albuquerque Smith Property
Santa Fe County
New Mexico 
SPA-2011-00244  Jurisdictional Determination  4/24/2013  6/12/2013 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Sacramento 

Great Salt Lake Minerals Box Elder County Utah

SPK-2007-0012  Jurisdictional Determination  4/20/2012  5/17/2013  No Merit 

Not Applicable

 
Sacramento Patey property, Wasatch County, Utah  SPK-1999-50107  Jurisdictional Determination  9/14/2012  5/29/2013  Had Merit  Maintained jurisdiction following District reconsideration 
Albuquerque

Calabacillas Arroyo, Sandoval County, New Mexico

SPA-2011-00386 Jurisdictional Determination 1/20/2012 11/08/2012 Had Merit Pending
San Francisco Pullman Ditch
San Mateo County
California 
SPN-2010-00191
 
Jurisdictional
Determination
 
1/04/2012
 
1/30/2012
 
Withdrawn 

Not Applicable

 
Los Angeles  Mission Gorge Quarry
San Diego County
California 
SPL-2010-00223-PJB  Jurisdictional Determination  12/27/2011  8/02/2012  Had Merit  Disclaimed Jurisdiction After District Reevaluation
Albuquerque Smith Property
Santa Fe County
New Mexico
SPA-2011-00244 Jurisdictional Determination 8/08/2011 10/25/2011 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Albuquerque  White Water Creek, Catron County, NM  200600470 Jurisdictional Determination  02/02/2011 03/22/2011 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Albuquerque  Saliz Creek
Catron County, NM
 
SPA-2010-00330-ABQ
Jurisdictional Determination 02/02/2011 03/22/2011 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Sacramento
Southern Parkway
Washington County
Utah
SPK-2000-50443 Jurisdictional Determination 12/29/2010 4/14/2011 Had Merit Disclaimed Jurisdiction after District Reevaluation
Sacramento
 Morgan Ranch,
Tehama County
California
SPK-2007-00642 Jurisdictional Determination
11/19/2010 3/8/2011 Had Merit Pending
Sacramento
Michigan Bar-Latrobe Road, El Dorado County
California
SPK-2009-00787 Jurisdictional Determination
1/04/2010 9/15/2010 Had Merit Maintained Jurisdiction after District reevaluation
Sacramento
Oasis Center
Shasta County,
California
SPK-2002-00338 Proffered Permit 10/08/2009 2/2/2011 Had Merit Issued Modified Permit following Remand
San Francisco
Napa County Airport
Napa County, California
2005-2970N Jurisdictional Determination 9/04/2009 1/21/10 Withdrawn
Not Applicable
San Francisco Napa Junction Road Property 26557N Jurisdictional Determination 6/26/2009 3/03/2010 Had Merit Maintained Jurisdiction after District Reevaluation
San Francisco Gunn Property
Napa County, California
2007-400783N Jurisdictional Determination 12/30/2008 3/20/2009 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Sacramento
Spanish Fork - Springville Airport, Utah County, Utah SPK-2005-50437 Jurisdictional Determination 12/18/2008 8/06/2009 No Merit  Not Applicable
Sacramento
Kevin Strait Property
Summit County, Utah
200450167 Jurisdictional Determination 12/02/2008 7/15/2009 Had Merit Maintained Jurisdiction after District Reevaluation
Sacramento
Hughes Property
Summit County, UT
200550599 Jurisdictional Determination 9/09/2008 2/10/2009  Had Merit Maintained Jurisdiction after District Reevaluation
San Francisco Grand View Terrace
San Mateo County, CA
2007-00560S Jurisdictional Determination 8/28/2008 10/21/2009  Had Merit Maintained Jurisdiction after District Reevaluation
Sacramento
Dias Lane Property
Placer County, CA
SPK-2007-02143 Jurisdictional Determination 8/12/2008 6/02/2009  Had Merit Maintained Jurisdiction after District Reevaluation
San Francisco Metropolitan Oakland
International Airport
Oakland, California
252600S Jurisdictional Determination
6/30/2008 6/02/2009  Had Merit Maintained Jurisdiction after District Reevaluation
Sacramento
Howell Property, Magna, Utah SPK-2008-00092-UO Jurisdictional Determination 4/29/2008 8/21/2008 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Sacramento
Linkside Place, Butte County, CA 200200475 Jurisdictional Determination
1/10/2008 12/17/2008 Had Merit  Maintained Jurisdiction after District reevaluation
Los Angeles
Holzmann Dock, La Paz County, AZ SPL-2008-00654-MB Denied Permit 1/03/2008 5/28/2008 Had Merit   Permit Denial
Sacramento
French Bar Bluffs, Stanislaus County, CA 200000223 Jurisdictional Determination 8/01/2007 11/20/2007 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Sacramento
Richard Mendenhall, Tenedor LLC 200650413 Jurisdictional Determination 6/11/2007 3/28/2008 Had Merit Disclaimed jurisdiction
Sacramento
Reynen & Bardis Communities (Roemer Ranch) Sacramento County, CA 200400627 Jurisdictional Determination
5/16/2007 11/07/2007 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Los Angeles
Collins Property, Mohave Valley, AZ 2006-01893-MB Permit Denial 5/07/2007 Not eligible for appeal.  Submitted after 60 day deadline Not Applicable Not Applicable
Sacramento
Mosher Road Property,
Sacramento County, CA
200500525 Jurisdictional Determination 1/23/2007 2/01/2008 Had Merit
Reduced Area of Jurisdiction after District Reevaluation
Sacramento
Silva Ranch Property, Sacramento County, CA 200500649
Jurisdictional Determination 1/8/2007
5/18/2007
Had Merit
Awaiting Appellant Action
Sacramento
Anderson Property, Blythe, CA
2006-01891-MB
Permit Denial
11/29/06
2/14/2007
No Merit
Not Applicable
San Francisco Berg Holdings, Port Sonoma, CA
290950N
Jurisdictional Determination
7/10/06
10/24/2006
Had Merit
Maintained Jurisdiction after District reevaluation
Sacramento
Boylan property, Frisco, CO 2006753033
Jurisdictional Determination 3/24/06
4/20/06
Not Accepted Not Applicable
Sacramento
Avery property, Bethel Island, CA
199400294
Jurisdictional Determination 2/21/06
4/13/06
Not Accepted
Not Applicable
Los Angeles
San Jacinto Property Owners Association, Perris, CA
200200081
Jurisdictional Determination 2/13/06
4/21/06
Not Accepted
Not Applicable
Sacramento
Joallan Lake Subdivision
Fresno County, CA
200400937
Jurisdictional Determination 12/16/05 6/16/06
Had Merit
 Disclaimed jurisdiction
Sacramento
Intrawest Brush Creek Development
Snowmass, CO
200475419
Proffered Permit
11/29/05
Appeal process terminated 2/21/06.  Permit decision elevated  to Division Engineer and permit with conditions issued. Not Applicable Not Applicable
Sacramento
Swenson Property
Spanish Fork, UT
200550291
Jurisdictional Determination
9/28/05
4/13/2006
Had Merit
Rescinded Jurisdiction after District reevaluation
Sacramento
Treasure Homes
Elk Grove, CA
200400036
Jurisdictional Determination 8/8/05
2/14/2006
Had Merit
Maintained Jurisdiction after District reevaluation
Sacramento
West Lake Village Site, Stockton, CA 200400279
Jurisdictional Determination 11/24/04
6/30/2005
Had Merit
Maintained Jurisdiction after District reevaluation
Los Angeles
Scalzo Family Trust Property,  San Juan Capistrano, CA 200401590-SJH
Jurisdictional Determination
9/30/04
Withdrawn
Not Applicable
Not Applicable
Sacramento
Wastewater Treatment Plan Expansion   Perry City, UT 200250435
Proffered Permit
9/14/04
12/22/04
Had Merit
Permit Denial
Sacramento
Sunquest Development, Syracuse, UT 199450037
Jurisdictional Determination 8/13/04
Withdrawn
Not Applicable District provided revised JD prior to appeal decision
Sacramento
Calute Homes (Fernwood Site)
North Ogden, UT
199950273
Jurisdictional Determination
8/09/04
Withdrawn
Not Applicable
District provided revised JD prior to appeal decision
Sacramento
1200 West St. Extension Site Perry City, UT
200250385
Jurisdictional Determination (resubmittal) 9/14/04
2/16/2005
No Merit
Not Applicable
Sacramento
1200 West St. Extension Site, Perry City, UT 200250385
Jurisdictional Determination 8/04/04
8/16/04
Not Accepted Not Applicable
Sacramento
Delta Breeze Vineyard, Lake County, CA 200000204
Proffered Permit
1/26/04
9/8/2004
Had Merit
District revised special conditions
Sacramento
AKT Development, Lot P, Sacramento, CA 199900712
Permit Denial
10/24/03
5/04/04
No Merit
Not Applicable
Sacramento
River Ridge Terrace, Redding, CA 200200349
Jurisdictional Determination 9/13/03
5/04/04
Had Merit
Modified Jurisdiction after District reevaluation
Sacramento

Katir property,  Olivehurst, CA

200200601
Jurisdictional Determination 9/10/03
3/26/04
Had Merit
Modified Jurisdiction after District reevaluation
Sacramento
Biggers property, Crested Butte, CO 200275257
Jurisdictional Determination 8/01/03
12/22/03
Had Merit
Maintained Jurisdiction after District reevaluation
Sacramento
Evergreen Development, Synderville, UT 200250344
Jurisdictional Determination 8/01/03
8/31/03
Not Accepted Not Applicable
Sacramento
Kaweah Delta Water Conservation District, Kaweah River downstream of Terminus Dam, Visalia, CA 200300194
Jurisdictional Determination
8/01/03
1/14/04
Had Merit
Request for jurisdictional determination withdrawn by applicant
Sacramento
Tule River Improvement Joint Powers Authority, Porter Slough and Tule River downstream of Success Dam, Visalia, CA 200300193
Jurisdictional Determination
7/25/03
1/14/04
Had Merit
Request for jurisdictional determination withdrawn by applicant
San Francisco
Alameda County, Juvenile Hall, Dublin, CA 26843S
Jurisdictional Determination 5/27/03
6/13/03
Not Accepted Not Applicable
Sacramento
Marek Property, Steamboat Springs, CO 200175341
Jurisdictional Determination 5/14/03
8/29/03
Had Merit
Maintained Jurisdiction after District reevaluation
Sacramento
Evergreen Development Inc. ,Synderville, UT 200250344
Jurisdictional Determination 5/07/03
6/04/03
Not Accepted Not Applicable
San Francisco
Gentry Property, Suisun City, CA 26613N
Jurisdictional Determination 5/02/03
Withdrawn
Not Applicable Not Applicable
Sacramento
Teichert Materials,  Truckee, CA 199200338
Jurisdictional Determination 4/25/03
Withdrawn
Not Applicable Not Applicable
San Francisco
Davenport property, Santa Rosa, CA 20651N
Jurisdictional Determination 12/30/02
4/29/03
No Merit
Not Applicable
Los Angeles
STANTEC, Valley Vista Property, Phoenix, AZ 2002-0132212-SDM
Jurisdictional Determination 11/06/02
1/31/03
Had Merit
Maintained Jurisdiction after District reevaluation
Sacramento
Aspen Meadows Subdivision, Truckee, CA 200200112
Jurisdictional Determination 10/11/02
Withdrawn
Not Applicable Not Applicable
Sacramento
Lakemont Homes, Reno, NV 200225006
Jurisdictional Determination 9/25/02
Withdrawn
Not Applicable Not Applicable
Sacramento
Kukal property, Montrose, CO 200275125
Jurisdictional Determination 6/17/02
9/25/02
No Merit
Not Applicable
Sacramento
Peterson property, Salt Lake City, UT 200050067
Jurisdictional Determination 5/07/02
8/28/02
No Merit
Not Applicable
Los Angeles
Desert Moon Shadows Estates, Buckeye, AZ 2001-01675-AP
Jurisdictional Determination 4/01/02
7/11/02
No Merit  Not Applicable
Sacramento
Peterson property, Salt Lake City, UT 200050067
Jurisdictional Determination 2/22/02
3/24/02
Not Accepted Not Applicable
Sacramento
Sun City Development, Lincoln, CA
199700375
Jurisdictional Determination
1/14/02
4/24/02
Had Merit
Modified Jurisdictional Determination after District reevaluation
Los Angeles
Molycorp Inc.         Mountain Pass, CA 200001678-AJS Jurisdictional Determination 12/18/01
1/15/02
Not Accepted Not Applicable
Sacramento
Ironton Site, Provo, Utah
200150240
Jurisdictional Determination 11/12/01
Withdrawn
Not Applicable Not Applicable
Sacramento
Golden State Developers, Tracy, CA
200100023
Jurisdictional Determination
7/20/01
10/25/01
Had Merit
Rescinded Jurisdictional  Determination after District reevaluation
San Francisco
Baccarat Fremont Developers, Fremont, CA 23205S
Jurisdictional Determination 7/09/01
10/25/01
Had Merit
Maintained Jurisdiction after District reevaluation
Los Angeles
Sunrise Office Park, Tucson, AZ 2001-00379-RJD
Jurisdictional Determination 5/14/01
9/07/01
No Merit
Not Applicable
Los Angeles Molycorp Inc.   Mountain Pass, CA 200001678-AJS Jurisdictional Determination 5/02/01 8/16/01 Had Merit Maintained Jurisdiction after further District  reevaluation
Los Angeles Molycorp Inc.   Mountain Pass, CA 200001678-AJS  Jurisdictional Determination   1/18/01  2/05/01 Not Accepted  Not Applicable
 
Los Angeles

Turner Property, Tucson AZ

2000-00554-RJD
Jurisdictional Determination 1/15/01
4/02/01
No Merit
Not Applicable
Sacramento
Roebbelen Land Company, Sundance Plaza Project,  Placerville, CA 199800257
Permit Denial
10/26/00
2/05/01
No Merit
Not Applicable
Los Angeles
King Ranch, Goodyear, AZ
1999-16526-EHB
Jurisdictional Determination 6/02/00
8/31/00
No Merit
Not Applicable
San Francisco
Murray Dam Committee.  Cazadero, CA 23493N
Permit Denial
2/03/00  5/02/00
Had Merit
Permit applicant did not submit necessary  application to State to obtain Water Quality Certification decision so Corps permit processing terminated